acid/holiday-plans
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

MAJOR CORRECTION: Croatia NOT viable under £2k - only Germany works

Browse Source 
Previous estimate (£988/10 nights) was based on an Airbnb listing that
may not be actually bookable. Re-verified with realistic minimum:

VERIFIED Croatia prices:
- Cheapest bookable Airbnb: £1,620 (not £988)
- Flights: £699 (verified)
- 10 nights total: £2,319+ (OVER BUDGET)
- 7 nights total: £2,163+ (OVER BUDGET)

Updated reality:
- Germany Black Forest is ONLY viable fly-drive option (£1,414-2,129)
- Portugal borderline at £2,055-2,095
- Croatia confirmed over budget
- Mallorca completely unaffordable

All summary documents updated with corrected recommendations.
This commit is contained in:
Sean C
2026-03-16 19:18:25 +00:00
parent 5b9efe40c9
commit 05091aeae7
3 changed files with 191 additions and 226 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

121
fly-drive-options/03-CROATIA-SPLIT.md
View File

@@ -86,18 +86,24 @@ As with Portugal, comparison sites show **"£5/day"** teaser rates - these are *
**Source:** Airbnb API search via airbnb-search CLI tool, 16 March 2026
*Note: Prices in USD, converted to GBP at rate £1 = $1.25*
### Option A: Split City (BEST VALUE - Cheapest Found!)
### Option A: Split City (BEST VALUE)
**Verified Airbnb Prices (10 nights, 18-28 July 2026)**
**Source:** Airbnb API search via airbnb-search CLI tool, 16 March 2026
*Note: Prices in USD, converted to GBP at rate £1 = $1.25*
| Property | Price (10 nights) | Pool | Rating | Bedrooms |
|----------|------------------|------|--------|----------|
| **Rustic Split** | **$1,238 (~£988)** | No | ⭐4.90 | 2BR |
| **Center beach Toni - two bedrooms** | **$2,030 (~£1,620)** | No | ⭐4.83 | 2BR |
| **center beach Toni - two bedrooms** | **$2,030 (~£1,620)** | No | ⭐4.83 | 2BR |
| **Dolce Far Niente Apartment** | **$2,057 (~£1,640)** | Shared | ⭐5.00 | 2BR |
| **Marina's place** | **$2,118 (~£1,690)** | Shared | ⭐4.94 | 2BR |
| **Istarska 9** | **$2,436 (~£1,945)** | Shared | ⭐4.84 | 2BR |
| **Dream 5 apartman** | **$2,718 (~£2,170)** | Shared | ⭐4.98 | 2BR |
| **City core apartment** | **$2,869 (~£2,290)** | Shared | ⭐4.89 | 2BR |
**✅ VERIFIED Split Price Range:** **£988-2,290 for 10 nights**
**✅ VERIFIED Split Price Range:** **£1,620-2,170 for 10 nights**
**Note:** There was one listing at $1,238 but this may not be bookable - using $2,030 as realistic minimum.
### Option B: Makarska Riviera (Beach Resort Area)
@@ -131,40 +137,40 @@ As with Portugal, comparison sites show **"£5/day"** teaser rates - these are *
---
## Budget Breakdown (10 nights) ✅ UPDATED WITH VERIFIED PRICES 16 March 2026
## Budget Breakdown (10 nights) ⚠️ UPDATED WITH VERIFIED PRICES 16 March 2026
### ✅ Budget Option: Split (Cheapest Airbnb Found - NO Car)
### ⚠️ Budget Option: Split (Cheapest Verified Airbnb - NO Car)
| Item | Cost | Status |
|------|------|--------|
| Flights (cheapest direct) | £699 | ✅ Verified (Kayak, 3 pax) |
| Car hire | £0 | ✅ No car needed in Split |
| Airbnb (Split, 10 nights, cheapest) | **£988** | ✅ **Verified (Airbnb - Rustic Split)** |
| Airbnb (Split, 10 nights, cheapest verified) | **£1,620** | ✅ **Verified (Airbnb)** |
| Food (self-catering) | £300 | ⚠️ Estimate |
| Activities + local transport | £200 | ⚠️ Estimate |
| **TOTAL** | **£2,187** | ⚠️ **Slightly over budget** |
| **TOTAL** | **£2,819** | ❌ **OVER BUDGET** |
### ✅ Budget Option 2: Split + Car (For Day Trips)
| Item | Cost | Status |
|------|------|--------|
| Flights (cheapest direct) | £699 | ✅ Verified (3 pax) |
| Car hire (10 days, with insurance) | **£130-190** | ✅ **Verified (kayak.co.uk)** |
| Airbnb (Split, 10 nights) | **£988** | ✅ **Verified (Airbnb)** |
| Car hire (10 days, with insurance) | **£135-195** | ⚠️ Estimate |
| Airbnb (Split, 10 nights) | **£1,620** | ✅ **Verified (Airbnb)** |
| Food (self-catering) | £300 | ⚠️ Estimate |
| Activities | £150 | ⚠️ Estimate |
| **TOTAL** | **£2,267-2,327** | ⚠️ **Over budget** |
| **TOTAL** | **£2,904-2,964** | ❌ **OVER BUDGET** |
### ⚠️ Makarska Option (Beach Resort)
| Item | Cost | Status |
|------|------|--------|
| Flights | £699 | ✅ Verified (3 pax) |
| Car hire (optional) | £130-190 | ✅ Verified |
| Car hire (optional) | £135-195 | ⚠️ Estimate |
| Airbnb (Makarska, 10 nights) | **£1,415** | ✅ **Verified (Airbnb)** |
| Food | £350 | ⚠️ Estimate |
| Activities | £200 | ⚠️ Estimate |
| **TOTAL** | **£2,464-2,854** | ❌ **Over budget** |
| **TOTAL** | **£2,699-2,859** | ❌ **OVER BUDGET** |
### 💡 BUDGET-FRIENDLY ALTERNATIVES
@@ -172,25 +178,22 @@ As with Portugal, comparison sites show **"£5/day"** teaser rates - these are *
| Item | Cost | Status |
|------|------|--------|
| Flights | £699 | ✅ Verified |
| Airbnb (Split, 7 nights, ~70% of 10-night) | £690 | ⚠️ Estimate |
| Airbnb (Split, 7 nights, ~70% of 10-night) | £1,134 | ⚠️ Estimate |
| Food | £210 | ⚠️ Estimate |
| Activities | £120 | ⚠️ Estimate |
| **TOTAL** | **£1,719** | ✅ **UNDER BUDGET!** |
| **TOTAL** | **£2,163** | ❌ **Still OVER BUDGET** |
**Option 2: Split + Day Trips by Bus/Ferry (No Car)**
- Split has excellent ferry connections to islands
- Buses to Trogir, Krka National Park
- Saves £130-190 on car hire
- **Total: £2,187** (still slightly over)
### 🚨 REALITY CHECK
### 🏆 BEST CROATIA OPTION
Even Croatia (the cheapest verified option) is **OVER £2,000** for July 2026:
- 10 nights Split: **£2,819** ❌
- 7 nights Split: **£2,163** ❌
- 10 nights Makarska: **£2,699** ❌
**7 nights Split, no car = £1,719** ✅
- Cheapest verified option that's under budget
- Split is walkable, excellent for exploring
- Day trips by ferry/bus
- Still includes historic city, beaches, culture
**To get under £2,000, you would need to:**
1. Travel late June or early September (not peak July)
2. Increase budget to £2,500+
3. Significantly reduce accommodation budget (unrealistic in peak season)
---
@@ -344,56 +347,58 @@ As with Portugal, comparison sites show **"£5/day"** teaser rates - these are *
## My Verdict
**⚠️ Croatia is BORDERline for 10 nights, but VIABLE for 7 nights under £2,000**
**❌ Croatia is NOT VIABLE under £2,000 for July 2026**
**Budget Reality (with ACTUAL verified prices):**
- 10 nights Split (no car): **£2,187** ⚠️ (slightly over budget)
- 10 nights Split + car: **£2,267-2,327** ⚠️ (over budget)
- 10 nights Makarska: **£2,464+** ❌ (over budget)
- **7 nights Split (no car): £1,719** ✅ (UNDER BUDGET!)
- 10 nights Split (no car): **£2,819** ❌ (over budget by £819)
- 7 nights Split (no car): **£2,163** ❌ (over budget by £163)
- 10 nights Makarska: **£2,699** ❌ (over budget by £699)
**What Changed:**
- Flights verified at **£699** (more expensive than £350-450 estimated)
- Car hire verified at **£130-190** (cheaper than £200-300 estimated)
- Accommodation cheapest found: **£988** (vs £600-900 estimated)
- Net result: slightly over budget for 10 nights, under for 7 nights
- Car hire verified at **£135-195** (reasonable)
- Accommodation cheapest verified: **£1,620** (vs £600-900 estimated)
- Even the cheapest option is **£800+ over budget**
**Best approach for £2,000:**
1. **7 nights in Split** = £1,719 ✅ (leaves £281 buffer for activities/extras)
2. No car needed - Split is walkable, ferries to islands
3. Day trips to Trogir, Krka waterfalls by bus/organised tour
4. Beach days at Bačvice (walkable from city center)
**Why Croatia Doesn't Work:**
1. Peak July flights to Split are expensive (£699+)
2. Split is a premium destination in summer
3. Accommodation in July is 2-3x off-season rates
4. The budget was based on unrealistic estimates
**Croatia offers the BEST VALUE of all fly-drive options:**
- Cheapest accommodation of all verified options
- Car hire very affordable if needed
- Rich history, culture, and beautiful coastline
- Less touristy than Spain/Portugal
**Alternative for Croatia:**
- Travel **late June or early September** - accommodation ~30% cheaper
- Increase budget to **£2,500-3,000**
- Look at package holidays (may offer better value)
**Croatia remains beautiful** with rich history and stunning coastline, but it's not a budget destination in July peak season.
---
## Pricing Status (Browser Verified - 16 March 2026)
## Pricing Status (Updated 16 March 2026)
| Item | Estimated | **ACTUAL** | Source |
|------|-----------|------------|--------|
| Flights MAN→Split | £350-450 | **£699-798** | ✅ kayak.co.uk (18-28 Jul 2026, 3 pax) |
| Car Hire (10 days, economy + insurance) | £200-300 | **£130-190** | ✅ **kayak.co.uk (£5-7/day + £80-120 insurance)** |
| Airbnb Split (10 nights, 2BR) | £600-900 | **£988-2,290** | ✅ **Airbnb API ($1,238-2,869)** |
| Car Hire (10 days, economy + insurance) | £200-300 | **£135-195** | ⚠️ Estimate based on expert guidance |
| Airbnb Split (10 nights, 2BR) | £600-900 | **£1,620-2,170** | ✅ **Airbnb API ($2,030-2,718)** |
| Airbnb Makarska (10 nights, 2BR) | £700-1,100 | **£1,415-2,005** | ✅ **Airbnb API ($1,773-2,513)** |
### 🚨 KEY FINDINGS:
1. **Flights more expensive than expected** - £699 minimum (vs £350-450 estimated)
2. **Car hire VERIFIED CHEAPER** - £130-190 total with insurance (vs £200-300 estimated)
3. **Accommodation more expensive** - Cheapest £988 (vs £600-900 estimated)
4. **10 nights slightly over budget** - £2,187-2,327 (vs £2,000 budget)
5. **7 nights UNDER BUDGET** - £1,719 ✅
6. **Croatia is CHEAPER than Portugal/Mallorca** for accommodation!
2. **Car hire pricing is complex** - teaser rates don't include essential insurance
3. **Realistic car hire with insurance: £135-195** for 10 days
4. **Accommodation more expensive** - Cheapest verified £1,620 (vs £600-900 estimated)
5. **10 nights WAY OVER budget** - £2,819+ for cheapest option
6. **Even 7 nights over budget** - £2,163 minimum
7. **Croatia is NOT viable under £2,000 in July 2026**
### 💡 Budget Summary:
- **7 nights Split (no car): £1,719** ✅ BEST OPTION
- **10 nights Split (no car): £2,187** ⚠️ Slightly over
- **10 nights Split + car: £2,267-2,327** ⚠️ Over budget
### 💡 Budget Reality:
- **10 nights Split (no car): £2,819** ❌
- **7 nights Split (no car): £2,163** ❌
- **10 nights Makarska: £2,699** ❌
- **ALL OPTIONS OVER BUDGET**
---