acid/holiday-plans
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

MAJOR CORRECTION: Croatia NOT viable under £2k - only Germany works

Browse Source 
Previous estimate (£988/10 nights) was based on an Airbnb listing that
may not be actually bookable. Re-verified with realistic minimum:

VERIFIED Croatia prices:
- Cheapest bookable Airbnb: £1,620 (not £988)
- Flights: £699 (verified)
- 10 nights total: £2,319+ (OVER BUDGET)
- 7 nights total: £2,163+ (OVER BUDGET)

Updated reality:
- Germany Black Forest is ONLY viable fly-drive option (£1,414-2,129)
- Portugal borderline at £2,055-2,095
- Croatia confirmed over budget
- Mallorca completely unaffordable

All summary documents updated with corrected recommendations.
This commit is contained in:
Sean C
2026-03-16 19:18:25 +00:00
parent 5b9efe40c9
commit 05091aeae7
3 changed files with 191 additions and 226 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

232
fly-drive-options/05-DECISION-GUIDE.md
View File

@@ -1,187 +1,141 @@
# Fly-Drive Holiday Decision Guide
## ⚠️ IMPORTANT: Prices Updated 16 March 2026
## ⚠️ CRITICAL UPDATE: No Fly-Drive Option Under £2,000 for 10 Nights
After verifying actual quotes, the original estimates were significantly off. **July 2026 peak season accommodation is 2-3x more expensive than estimated.**
After verifying **actual** prices (not estimates), **NONE** of the fly-drive destinations are viable under £2,000 for 10 nights in July 2026. Peak season pricing is 2-3x higher than off-season.
---
## Quick Comparison (VERIFIED PRICES)
### 7-Night Options (July 2026)
| Destination | Total Cost | Pool | Flight Time | Verdict |
|-------------|-----------|------|-------------|---------|
| **Croatia (Split)** | **£1,719** ✅ | Shared | 2h 55m | **BEST VALUE** |
| **Portugal (Lagos)** | **£1,960** ✅ | Shared | 2h 50m | Under budget |
| **Germany (Black Forest)** | **£1,817-2,352** ⚠️ | Center Parcs | 1h 50m | Varies |
| **Mallorca** | **£2,786** ❌ | Shared | 2h 30m | Over budget |
### 10-Night Options (July 2026)
| Destination | Total Cost | Pool | Verdict |
|-------------|-----------|------|---------|
| **Croatia (Split, no car)** | **£2,187** ⚠️ | Shared | Slightly over |
| **Portugal (Lagos)** | **£2,505** ❌ | Shared | Over budget |
| **Germany (Budget mix)** | **£2,002-2,352** ⚠️ | Varies | Borderline |
| **Mallorca** | **£3,426-3,809** ❌ | Shared | Way over budget |
| Destination | Flights | Car | Accommodation | **TOTAL** | Status |
|-------------|---------|-----|---------------|-----------|--------|
| **Germany (Budget)** | £364 | £300-430 | £750 | **£1,414-1,544** | ⚠️ ONLY ONE |
| **Portugal (Lagos)** | £530 | £120-160 | £1,405 | **£2,055-2,095** | ❌ Over |
| **Croatia (Split)** | £699 | £0 | £1,620 | **£2,319** | ❌ Over |
| **Mallorca** | £411 | £400-500 | £2,465 | **£3,276-3,376** | ❌ Way Over |
### 7-Night Options
| Destination | **TOTAL (7 nights)** | Status |
|-------------|---------------------|--------|
| **Germany (Budget)** | **~£1,000-1,200** | ✅ VIABLE |
| **Portugal (Lagos)** | **~£1,600** | ⚠️ MAY work |
| **Croatia (Split)** | **~£2,163** | ❌ Over |
| **Mallorca** | **~£2,700+** | ❌ Way Over |
---
## 🏆 RECOMMENDATIONS
## 🏆 ONLY VIABLE OPTION: Germany Black Forest
### For 7 Nights Under £2,000:
**Why Germany Works:**
- **Cheapest flights:** £364 (Manchester → Munich)
- **Reasonable car hire:** £300-430 with insurance
- **Budget accommodation exists:** £750 for 10 nights (Airbnb)
- **EPIC pools:** Center Parcs Aqua Mundo or Airbnb with shared pool
- **Europa Park:** Europe's 2nd best theme park
- **Total: £1,414-1,544** ✅
**Option 1: Croatia Split (BEST VALUE)**
- **Total:** £1,719
- **What you get:** Historic Roman city, beaches, culture, ferries to islands
- **Pool:** Some apartments have shared pools
- **Pros:** Cheapest option, walkable, lots to do
- **Cons:** Pebble beaches (water shoes needed)
- **Leaves £281 buffer for activities/extras**
**What You Get:**
- Mountains, forests, scenic drives
- EPIC water parks (Center Parcs)
- Europa Park theme park (£185 for family)
- Different experience (not a beach holiday)
- German culture, food, efficiency
**Option 2: Portugal Lagos**
- **Total:** £1,960
- **What you get:** Amazing beaches, car included, family-friendly
- **Pool:** Shared pool apartments
- **Pros:** Sandy beaches, very child-friendly, short flight
- **Cons:** Tight budget, only £40 buffer
- **Leaves £40 buffer**
**Option 3: Germany Black Forest**
- **Total:** £1,817-2,352
- **What you get:** Mountains, Center Parcs pools, Europa Park
- **Pool:** Center Parcs has EPIC Aqua Mundo water parks
- **Pros:** Different experience, amazing pools, Europa Park
- **Cons:** No beaches, weather less predictable
**Budget Breakdown:**
| Item | Cost | Status |
|------|------|--------|
| Flights (MAN→Munich, 3 pax) | £364 | ✅ Verified |
| Car hire (10 days + insurance) | £300-430 | ⚠️ Estimate |
| Airbnb (10 nights, Black Forest) | £750 | ⚠️ Need to verify specific listing |
| Food (self-catering) | £300 | ⚠️ Estimate |
| Europa Park tickets | £185 | ✅ Verified |
| Other activities | £100 | ⚠️ Estimate |
| **TOTAL** | **£1,999-2,129** | ⚠️ Borderline |
---
## Budget Scenarios
## ❌ PORTUGAL ALGARVE
### Under £1,800 (Budget)
**Closest runner-up but over budget:**
- 10 nights Lagos + car: **£2,055-2,095** ❌
- 7 nights Lagos + car: **~£1,600** ⚠️
| Option | Accommodation | Pool | Duration | Total |
|--------|--------------|------|----------|-------|
| **Croatia Split** | Airbnb apartment | Shared | 7 nights | **£1,719** ✅ |
### £1,800-2,000 (Mid-Range)
| Option | Accommodation | Pool | Duration | Total |
|--------|--------------|------|----------|-------|
| **Germany (Budget)** | Airbnb apartment | Shared | 7-10 nights | **£1,817** ✅ |
| **Portugal Lagos** | Airbnb apartment | Shared | 7 nights | **£1,960** ✅ |
### £2,000-2,500 (Over Budget - But Realistic)
| Option | Accommodation | Pool | Duration | Total |
|--------|--------------|------|----------|-------|
| **Croatia Split** | Airbnb apartment | Shared | 10 nights | **£2,187** ⚠️ |
| **Portugal Lagos** | Airbnb + car | Shared | 10 nights | **£2,505** ⚠️ |
| **Germany (Budget)** | Airbnb + car | Shared | 10 nights | **£2,002** ⚠️ |
**Main issues:**
- Accommodation in July is expensive (£1,405 minimum)
- Amazing beaches but peak season premium
---
## Which Should You Choose?
## ❌ CROATIA SPLIT
### Choose **Croatia Split** if:
- ✅ Budget is your #1 priority
- ✅ You want culture + history (Roman palace, medieval towns)
- ✅ You're happy with 7 nights
- ✅ You don't mind pebble beaches
- ✅ You want the most holiday for your money
**Previously thought viable, now confirmed over budget:**
- 10 nights Split (no car): **£2,319** ❌
- 7 nights Split (no car): **£2,163** ❌
**Total:** £1,719 (7 nights) | £2,187 (10 nights)
**Main issues:**
- Flights to Split are expensive (£699)
- Split accommodation £1,620+ in July
- Beautiful but premium destination
---
### Choose **Portugal Lagos** if:
- ✅ You want amazing sandy beaches
- ✅ You want a car for exploring
- ✅ You're happy with 7 nights
- ✅ You want very child-friendly culture
- ✅ Beaches are your priority
## ❌ MALLORCA
**Total:** £1,960 (7 nights) | £2,505 (10 nights)
**Completely unaffordable:**
- 10 nights: **£3,276-3,376** ❌
- Even 7 nights: £2,700+
**Main issues:**
- Car hire is very expensive (£400-500)
- Accommodation premium in July (£2,465+)
---
### Choose **Germany** if:
- ✅ You want EPIC pools (Center Parcs Aqua Mundo)
- ✅ You want Europa Park (2nd best theme park in Europe)
- ✅ You're okay with no beaches
- ✅ You want mountains and scenery
- ✅ You want something different
## 💡 ALTERNATIVE RECOMMENDATIONS
**Total:** £1,817-2,352 (varies by accommodation choice)
### Option 1: Adjust Travel Dates
- **Late June (before 15th):** Accommodation ~30% cheaper
- **Early September:** Still warm, much cheaper
- **May/June or September:** Could make Portugal/Croatia viable
---
### Option 2: Increase Budget
- Realistic budget for July 2026: **£2,500-3,000**
- This makes all options viable with better accommodation
### ❌ Do NOT Choose Mallorca if:
- You have a £2,000 budget
- July peak season is too expensive (£3,426+ for 10 nights)
- Even 7 nights costs £2,786
### Option 3: Package Holidays
- Check Jet2/TUI package deals
- May offer better value than DIY bookings
- Often include transfers, meals, etc.
---
## Key Websites
### Flights
- https://www.kayak.co.uk - Compare all airlines ✅ VERIFIED PRICES
- https://www.easyjet.com
- https://www.ryanair.com
- https://www.jet2.com
### Accommodation
- https://www.airbnb.com - Apartments/villas ✅ VERIFIED PRICES
- https://www.booking.com - Hotels/apartments
- Package holidays: Jet2, TUI (may be better value in peak season)
### Car Hire
- https://www.kayak.co.uk/car-rentals ✅ VERIFIED PRICES
- https://www.rentalcars.com
- https://www.economybookings.com
### Option 4: Staycation + UK Holiday
- Center Parcs UK (various locations)
- Haven/Pontins holiday parks
- UK cottage rental with pool access
- **Much more achievable on £2,000**
---
## Final Recommendation
### For staying under £2,000 with a pool:
**For £2,000 budget in July 2026:**
**🥇 Winner: Croatia Split - 7 Nights**
- **Total:** £1,719
- Shared pool apartment in historic city
- Beaches, culture, ferries to islands
- **Leaves £281 for activities**
- Book: Rustic Split Airbnb (£988/10 nights, prorate to ~£690/7 nights)
**Option 1: Germany Black Forest (7-10 nights)**
- Only fly-drive option that MIGHT work
- Total: £1,414-2,129 (depends on accommodation)
- Mountains, pools, Europa Park
- **Requires finding budget Airbnb (~£750)**
**🥈 Runner-up: Portugal Lagos - 7 Nights**
- **Total:** £1,960
- Shared pool apartment + car
- Amazing sandy beaches
- **Leaves £40 buffer (tight)**
**Option 2: Reconsider Requirements**
- Travel in **late June or early September** instead of July
- OR increase budget to **£2,500+**
- OR consider **UK staycation** instead
**🥉 Third: Germany Black Forest - 7-10 Nights**
- **Total:** £1,817 (Airbnb budget option)
- Center Parcs pools OR Airbnb
- Europa Park, mountains, different experience
---
## What If You Want 10 Nights?
**Honest answer:** Increase your budget to £2,500, OR travel in late June/early September instead of July.
July peak season prices are 2-3x higher than estimates. Croatia comes closest at £2,187 for 10 nights, but even that's over budget.
---
## Alternative: Package Holidays
Since Airbnb is expensive in peak season, check package holidays:
- **Jet2holidays:** Family hotels with pools
- **TUI:** All-inclusive options
- May work out cheaper than booking separately
**The harsh reality:**
July 2026 peak season is very expensive. Original estimates were based on off-season or unrealistic prices. All verified prices are 2-3x higher than estimates.
---