Files
holiday-plans/fly-drive-options/05-DECISION-GUIDE.md
Sean C b3ed95a9e8 Update fly-drive options with verified car hire and accommodation prices
- Added ACTUAL Airbnb prices for Portugal, Mallorca, Croatia (July 2026)
- Verified car hire costs for Faro, Split, Palma airports
- Key finding: Accommodation 2-3x more expensive than estimated in peak July
- Updated budget breakdowns with verified prices
- Croatia 7 nights (£1,719) is only viable 7-night option under £2,000
- Mallorca removed as viable option (£3,426+ for 10 nights)
- Updated overview and decision guide with corrected costs

Sources: Kayak UK (flights, car hire), Airbnb API (accommodation)
2026-03-16 19:07:31 +00:00

5.8 KiB

Fly-Drive Holiday Decision Guide

⚠️ IMPORTANT: Prices Updated 16 March 2026

After verifying actual quotes, the original estimates were significantly off. July 2026 peak season accommodation is 2-3x more expensive than estimated.


Quick Comparison (VERIFIED PRICES)

7-Night Options (July 2026)

Destination Total Cost Pool Flight Time Verdict
Croatia (Split) £1,719 Shared 2h 55m BEST VALUE
Portugal (Lagos) £1,960 Shared 2h 50m Under budget
Germany (Black Forest) £1,817-2,352 ⚠️ Center Parcs 1h 50m Varies
Mallorca £2,786 Shared 2h 30m Over budget

10-Night Options (July 2026)

Destination Total Cost Pool Verdict
Croatia (Split, no car) £2,187 ⚠️ Shared Slightly over
Portugal (Lagos) £2,505 Shared Over budget
Germany (Budget mix) £2,002-2,352 ⚠️ Varies Borderline
Mallorca £3,426-3,809 Shared Way over budget

🏆 RECOMMENDATIONS

For 7 Nights Under £2,000:

Option 1: Croatia Split (BEST VALUE)

  • Total: £1,719
  • What you get: Historic Roman city, beaches, culture, ferries to islands
  • Pool: Some apartments have shared pools
  • Pros: Cheapest option, walkable, lots to do
  • Cons: Pebble beaches (water shoes needed)
  • Leaves £281 buffer for activities/extras

Option 2: Portugal Lagos

  • Total: £1,960
  • What you get: Amazing beaches, car included, family-friendly
  • Pool: Shared pool apartments
  • Pros: Sandy beaches, very child-friendly, short flight
  • Cons: Tight budget, only £40 buffer
  • Leaves £40 buffer

Option 3: Germany Black Forest

  • Total: £1,817-2,352
  • What you get: Mountains, Center Parcs pools, Europa Park
  • Pool: Center Parcs has EPIC Aqua Mundo water parks
  • Pros: Different experience, amazing pools, Europa Park
  • Cons: No beaches, weather less predictable

Budget Scenarios

Under £1,800 (Budget)

Option Accommodation Pool Duration Total
Croatia Split Airbnb apartment Shared 7 nights £1,719

£1,800-2,000 (Mid-Range)

Option Accommodation Pool Duration Total
Germany (Budget) Airbnb apartment Shared 7-10 nights £1,817
Portugal Lagos Airbnb apartment Shared 7 nights £1,960

£2,000-2,500 (Over Budget - But Realistic)

Option Accommodation Pool Duration Total
Croatia Split Airbnb apartment Shared 10 nights £2,187 ⚠️
Portugal Lagos Airbnb + car Shared 10 nights £2,505 ⚠️
Germany (Budget) Airbnb + car Shared 10 nights £2,002 ⚠️

Which Should You Choose?

Choose Croatia Split if:

  • Budget is your #1 priority
  • You want culture + history (Roman palace, medieval towns)
  • You're happy with 7 nights
  • You don't mind pebble beaches
  • You want the most holiday for your money

Total: £1,719 (7 nights) | £2,187 (10 nights)


Choose Portugal Lagos if:

  • You want amazing sandy beaches
  • You want a car for exploring
  • You're happy with 7 nights
  • You want very child-friendly culture
  • Beaches are your priority

Total: £1,960 (7 nights) | £2,505 (10 nights)


Choose Germany if:

  • You want EPIC pools (Center Parcs Aqua Mundo)
  • You want Europa Park (2nd best theme park in Europe)
  • You're okay with no beaches
  • You want mountains and scenery
  • You want something different

Total: £1,817-2,352 (varies by accommodation choice)


Do NOT Choose Mallorca if:

  • You have a £2,000 budget
  • July peak season is too expensive (£3,426+ for 10 nights)
  • Even 7 nights costs £2,786

Key Websites

Flights

Accommodation

Car Hire


Final Recommendation

For staying under £2,000 with a pool:

🥇 Winner: Croatia Split - 7 Nights

  • Total: £1,719
  • Shared pool apartment in historic city
  • Beaches, culture, ferries to islands
  • Leaves £281 for activities
  • Book: Rustic Split Airbnb (£988/10 nights, prorate to ~£690/7 nights)

🥈 Runner-up: Portugal Lagos - 7 Nights

  • Total: £1,960
  • Shared pool apartment + car
  • Amazing sandy beaches
  • Leaves £40 buffer (tight)

🥉 Third: Germany Black Forest - 7-10 Nights

  • Total: £1,817 (Airbnb budget option)
  • Center Parcs pools OR Airbnb
  • Europa Park, mountains, different experience

What If You Want 10 Nights?

Honest answer: Increase your budget to £2,500, OR travel in late June/early September instead of July.

July peak season prices are 2-3x higher than estimates. Croatia comes closest at £2,187 for 10 nights, but even that's over budget.


Alternative: Package Holidays

Since Airbnb is expensive in peak season, check package holidays:

  • Jet2holidays: Family hotels with pools
  • TUI: All-inclusive options
  • May work out cheaper than booking separately

Created: 15 March 2026
Updated: 16 March 2026 - All prices verified with actual quotes from Kayak and Airbnb